PAYE vs Umbrella

PAYE vs Umbrella Company

In case being a sole trader or a limited company owner isn’t intended for you, you have two principle finance alternatives as a project worker: PAYE vs Umbrella. However, which one would it be advisable for you to pick?

Regardless of whether you’re new to contracting, or then again in case you’ve been doing it for quite a long time, settling on the right finance choice is essential. Thus, we’ve investigated the vital contrasts between contracting through an umbrella company and contracting through agency PAYE.


Whether you are looking for compliance-only services, all-inclusive packages with monthly support.


We have solutions for all your business needs!

In This Article:

  • What is an Umbrella Company?
  • What is Agency PAYE?
  • What’s the Difference? –  PAYE vs Umbrella?


A Guide on Umbrella company and agency PAYE


What is an Umbrella Company?

An umbrella company gives ceaseless work to project workers who are on fixed-term tasks. Umbrella organizations go about as go-betweens between the project worker and their agency/end customer. With an umbrella company, you’ll stay at work when your agreement closes, or when you’re searching for another task. Your agreement will likewise persevere in case you’re dealing with more than one task.


What is Agency PAYE?

With agency PAYE (Pay As You Earn), a worker for hire gets utilized by their business/enlistment agency for the length of the agreement they have with their end customer. They’re paid immediately, through the agency’s finance.

Not at all like the progression of work between gets that umbrella organization to give, an agency PAYE laborer’s business closes when their agreement with their customer wraps up. Also, offices will in general offer lower rates to their own PAYE laborers. That is rather than the frequently inspired rates offered to project workers utilized by umbrella organizations.


Due to extensive demand, we now offer compliance-only packages to SME’s. 


What’s the Difference? –  PAYE vs Umbrella?

Before you conclude whether to get paid through an umbrella company or by means of agency PAYE, you need to consider things like expense, benefits, costs, protection, HR backing, and congruity of business. Thus, we should investigate everyone thusly to perceive how they coordinate.

1) COST: There’s regularly no expense to working through agency PAYE. Nonetheless, to cover the edge and different work costs, (for example, the Apprenticeship Levy), offices frequently inspire contracted rates for workers for hire who choose to go umbrella.

An umbrella company’s edge is the solitary thing that should change between suppliers. For example, some umbrella organizations guarantee obviously high salaries. This frequently includes covering less expense and National Insurance commitments (NICs).

The public authority’s recommendation on this is basic: ‘these plans don’t work. By utilizing them you might be partaking in charge aversion’. Work with the understanding that on the off chance that it sounds unrealistic (comparable to the burden). It’s normal since it is. With our umbrella company arrangement, you possibly pay an edge when we measure your payslip. In this way, you will not pay a penny in case you’re not working.

2) Employment Benefits: On two occasions, you’ll become a worker of the PAYE vs umbrella. Every association will deal with your administrator and finance. What’s more, under the two choices, you will get burdened under PAYE.

The thing that matters is, an umbrella company will be your lone boss if you’re on an agreement. That coherence of business will help while applying for a home loan or credit. Though, with agency PAYE, each new agreement is an alternate run of work.

Regardless of whether you go PAYE vs umbrella, you will approach legal business rights, like debilitated compensation. Contingent upon the umbrella company, however, you could likewise approach certain clinical wellbeing plans as well. Also benefits plans and markdown offers. We could likewise place you in contact with our monetary arranging group. They give industry-driving help to home loans, protection, and other monetary requirements.

3) Expenses: As either an umbrella representative or an agency PAYE specialist, you will get your wages by means of PAYE. With an umbrella company, however, you could be qualified for certain business-related costs. For example, when you register with us, we’ll request that you complete our ‘specialist survey’. This will decide your qualification to guarantee ‘permissible costs’.

Permissible costs are costs that are “brought about entirely, only and essentially in the presentation of your obligations”. In case you’re qualified for guarantee costs, you can present your case through our elite online entryway.

4) Insurance: Whichever choice you pick, you will require protection. The better organizations/umbrella organizations will give the cover you need to play out your obligations. Some umbrella organizations additionally give wellbeing, life, and mishap protection at no additional expense.

For example, with us, you’re covered by Public and Employers’ Liability protection, just as Professional Indemnity protection.

5) IR35: Changes to (IR35) off-finance working in the private area come into power in April 2021. The point is to forestall people who ought to be seen as representatives, from offering their administrations through a restricted company misguidedly. IR35 impacts the individuals who dishonestly position themselves as sole brokers/restricted organizations.

Along these lines, by and large, umbrella company representatives and agency PAYE laborers are outside of IR35.

6) Support: Employees ought to approach inside HR support as and when they need proficient exhortation or direction. This incorporates anything from notice or pays questions, to unjustifiable excusal. The quality and dependability of this help differ relying upon the business.

Be that as it may, regardless of whether you go PAYE vs umbrella, you need to factor in likely times of trouble.

For example, while an agency gets paid by the end customer, an umbrella company accepts their pay from the project worker (edge). Along these lines, there’s a convention to recommend that it’s simpler for them to act to your greatest advantage.


Is Umbrella Better than Agency PAYE?

PAYE vs Umbrella? As a rule, in the event that you:

  • Work on various agreements at the same time
  • Want the advantages and security of consistent business
  • Are probably going to guarantee for movement or means costs



Umbrella company work is the most ideal alternative for you.

On the other hand, in the event that you:

  • Intend to contract for a brief period – taking on a couple of agreements (not simultaneously) prior to returning into super durable business
  • Want to get paid and get your agreements sourced by a similar association, for example, no outsider

Agency PAYE could be a superior course for you.

How would I get paid through a PAYE Umbrella Company?

Umbrella organizations work as businesses for their project worker representatives. It works like this:

The agency/end customer pays a project worker’s ‘contracted rate’ to the umbrella company.

The umbrella company deals with the legal work costs for the worker for hire. They work out the project workers ‘ all-out net compensation.

They then, at that point pay legal allowances, for example, Income Tax and NICs, to HMRC before the project worker accepts their net bring home pay similarly as a super durable representative.

Umbrella organizations shoulder the authoritative and regulatory weight of finance – not you. It’s the issue-free way to deal with contracts.



You may likewise see self as evaluation as an option in contrast to umbrella or PAYE. With an umbrella company/agency PAYE, charges get deducted before you accept your wages. Then again, those on self-appraisal are needed to pay the expense they owe either month to month, quarterly, or every year themselves.

With self-appraisal expense forms, it’s ideal to look for the assistance of a bookkeeper or duty subject matter expert. Self-appraisal can make it harder to deal with your pay, with the need to keep funds to the side for single amount installments as and when required.


Interested in accounting and taxation services? Why not speak to one of our qualified accountants? Give us a call on 0203 4411 258 or request a callback. We are available from 9:00 am – 05:30 pm Monday to Friday.


Disclaimer: This article provides general information on PAYE vs umbrella.

Request A Callback

Call Now